On October 15, the City of Longville escalated its call for Minnesota DNR Commissioner Sarah Strommen to approve a temporary sandbagging of the rock arch rapids (RAR) outlet on Girl Lake.
The RAR outlet replaced the old Girl Lake dam that had been in-place for decades. Many area residents believe that defects in the design or implementation of the RAR is now allowing excess water to drain from the Woman Lake chain of lakes.
Over 1200 people have signed an on-line petition at https://womanlake.org/ calling for an independent review of the RAR outlet. People have expressed a range of concerns, including the inability to access their property on the lake through normal navigation channels, damaging outboard motors when hitting submerged obstacles, having to purchase additional dock sections, impacts on wildlife habitat and decreased property values.
Most importantly, people have commented on how lower water levels are affecting normal recreational activities with family members. One elderly couple commented on how they were not able to take their grandchildren fishing when they came to visit because water levels were too low to get their boat off the lift.
During the press conference, the Mayor for the City of Longville, Floyd “Jocko” Kline, reiterated the City’s request originally made in a letter to Commissioner on September 22. The request was made after an independent survey revealed a discrepancy between the elevation that was permitted and the actual elevation of the RAR. As of today, the Commissioner has failed to approve the sandbagging request.
“It’s now been over three weeks since we originally asked the Commissioner to temporarily stop the flow of water over the RAR,” said Kline. “People in our community are losing patience with Commissioner Strommen. The Commissioner has the authority to order this action under Minnesota law. Many people believe inaction on the part of the Commissioner is simply a delay tactic to wait until winter when no action can be taken.”
The city’s request was limited and non-prejudicial. It did not ask the DNR to set a new official lake level or lock in a permanent redesign. It sought only reversible interim steps—sandbags, temporary barriers, or covering specific openings—while the independent engineering review proceeds. Minnesota statutes place administration of waters of the state, lake levels, and control structures with the Commissioner and authorize examination and corrective action where warranted.
Joel Tosso from Barr Engineering is now leading the City’s independent review of the RAR outlet. Toso holds both a PhD and PE degrees. He is a senior water resources engineer with more than 40 years of experience involving hydrologic and hydraulic modeling, flood forecasting and dam engineering. Toso also taught applied hydrology and hydraulics at the University of Minnesota for nearly 20 years.
Toso, who was unable to attend the press conference, echoed Mayor Kline’s request during a phone conversation on Wednesday. “Temporarily sandbagging the RAR while we complete our independent review is a perfectly reasonable request,” said Toso. “We remain hopeful that the Commissioner will expedite her approval so we can complete our investigation before the water begins to freeze-up.”
A group of concerned residents created an informal advocacy organization when the local lake association declined to get involved. The group, called Woman Lake Action (WLA), has submitted data practices requests to the DNR, invited local lawmakers to visit the community, created a website for the petition drive, distributed law signs, run newspaper advertisements and hosted a public information session on the subject.
Jeff Davis, a spokesperson for WLA, also spoke at Thursday’s press conference. “Some Minnesotans may wonder why they should care about water levels on the Woman Lake chain,” said Davis. “I would argue that anyone who enjoys fishing walleye in the state of Minnesota should be concerned.” Davis went on to explain that the Boy River flowing between Child and Woman lakes is a major source for walleye fry which are ultimately stocked in other lakes. Davis contends that the DNR’s ability to do its spring stripping on Boy River is in jeopardy due to low water levels.
Davis went on to announced the launch of a new campaign designed to put pressure on Commissioner Strommen to approve the sandbagging operation.
“We are going to make Commissioner Strommen famous in the community of Longville,” said Davis. “Pallets of sandbags will be placed at the RAR with a large banner stating ‘Waiting On The DNR’. Every time someone drives through the city of Longville, they are going to see a stack of sandbags along the highway with Commissioner’s Strommen’s phone number.”
The DNR has repeatedly cited drought conditions as the primary explanation for low water levels in the Woman Lake chain of lakes. While WLA acknowledges drought conditions are partially responsible, they believe an independent review is required to rule-out the possibility that the RAR is discharging excess water.
“The standard that must be met by the DNR and Cass County is for the new RAR outlet to have a hydrologically equivalent performance when compared to the old dam,” said Davis. “I trust the observations of people in the community, many who have been on the lake chain for 50 years or more, who believe there’s something amiss with the RAR outlet.”
Davis commented during the meeting that WLA had just published a video on its website at https://womanlake.org/ in which various members of the community expressed their concerns about low water levels related to the RAR outlet.